Fee Dispute Hotline
(312) 907-7275

Assisting with High-Stakes Attorney Fee Disputes

The NALFA

News Blog

Category: Litigation Financing

ABA Adopts Best Practices for Third-Party Litigation Finance

August 4, 2020

A recent American Lawyer story by Dan Packel, “ABA Adopts Best Practices for Third-Party Litigation Finance” reports that the American Bar Association’s House of Delegates overwhelmingly voted to approve a new set of best practices for litigation funding arrangements, updating their guidance on the increasingly popular tool for the first time since 2012.  The report, which outlines a list of issues lawyers should consider before entering into agreements with outside funders, cleared the body by a vote of 366 to 10.

While the document avoids taking a position on the use of outside funding, it recommends that lawyers detail all arrangements in writing, while making clear the non-recourse nature of the investment.  Lawyers are also advised to ensure that the client retains control of the matter.  “The litigation should be managed and controlled by the party and the party’s counsel,” the report asserts.  “Limitations on a third-party funder’s involvement in, or direct or indirect control of or input into (or receipt of notice of), either day-to-day or broader litigation management and on all key issues (such as strategy and settlement) should be addressed in the funding agreement.”

The report also cautions attorneys against providing advice to funders about the merits of any given case, warning that this could raise concerns about the waiver of attorney-client privilege and also expose lawyers to claims that they have an obligation to update this guidance as the litigation develops.

Zachary Krug, a former Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan litigator who now works as a senior investment adviser with Woodsford Litigation funding, suggested this concern was misguided.  “Courts have been fairly consistent in protecting such communications under the work product doctrine,” he said in an email.

He also cautioned that the guidance could backfire in an environment where critics of litigation funding are already arguing that the availability of outside capital may lead to an increase in unmeritorious lawsuits.  “If our concern is making sure good cases get funded—and bad ones don’t—this seems like a problematic and short-sighted approach,” he said.

The report aims to stay neutral on a number of other contested issues surrounding the practice of litigation funding. In a controversial 2018 ethics opinion, the New York City Bar Association warned that paying funders through attorney fees could violate ethics rules over fee splitting.  “Positions on fee splitting, however, are far from unanimous; the New York City Bar Opinion is not the ‘law of the land’ outside of its reach, nor are opinions or approaches that contradict the New York City Bar Opinion,” the report said.

Likewise, opponents of the practice, namely business groups led by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, have pushed for rules requiring mandatory disclosure of funding arrangements during litigation.  The report does not take a stance on whether disclosures to judges or adversaries should be obligatory.  But in a footnote, it urges lawyers to be prepared for the prospect of arrangements being scrutinized.

“A careful lawyer will assure that the written undertakings accurately reflect that the client retains control of the litigation, that disclosures to the funder are limited so as not to create risks of waiver of attorney-client privilege or work product, and that the attorney retains and protects his or her ability to exercise independent professional judgment,” it said.

The Nation’s Top Attorney Fee Experts of 2020

June 24, 2020

NALFA, a non-profit group, is building a worldwide network of attorney fee expertise. Our network includes members, faculty, and fellows with expertise on the reasonableness of attorney fees.  We help organize and recognize qualified attorney fee experts from across the U.S. and around the globe.  Our attorney fee experts also include court adjuncts such as bankruptcy fee examiners, special fee masters, and fee dispute neutrals.

Every year, we announce the nation's top attorney fee experts.  Attorney fee experts are retained by fee-seeking or fee-challenging parties in litigation to independently prove reasonable attorney fees and expenses in court or arbitration.  The following NALFA profile quotes are based on bio, CV, case summaries and case materials submitted to and verified by us.  Here are the nation's top attorney fee experts of 2020:

"The Nation's Top Attorney Fee Expert"
John D. O'Connor
O'Connor & Associates
San Francisco, CA
 
"Over 30 Years of Legal Fee Audit Expertise"
Andre E. Jardini
KPC Legal Audit Services, Inc.
Glendale, CA

"The Nation's Top Bankruptcy Fee Examiner"
Robert M. Fishman
Cozen O'Connor
Chicago, IL

"Widely Respected as an Attorney Fee Expert"
Elise S. Frejka
Frejka PLLC
New York, NY
 
"Experienced on Analyzing Fees, Billing Entries for Fee Awards"
Robert L. Kaufman
Woodruff Spradlin & Smart
Costa Mesa, CA

"Highly Skilled on a Range of Fee and Billing Issues"
Daniel M. White
White Amundson APC
San Diego, CA
 
"Extensive Expertise on Attorney Fee Matters in Common Fund Litigation"
Craig W. Smith
Robbins Arroyo LLP
San Diego, CA
 
"Highly Experienced in Dealing with Fee Issues Arising in Complex Litigation"
Marc M. Seltzer
Susman Godfrey LLP
Los Angeles, CA

"Total Mastery in Resolving Complex Attorney Fee Disputes"
Peter K. Rosen
JAMS
Los Angeles, CA
 
"Understands Fees, Funding, and Billing Issues in Cross Border Matters"
Glenn Newberry
Eversheds Sutherland
London, UK
 
"Solid Expertise with Fee and Billing Matters in Complex Litigation"
Bruce C. Fox
Obermayer Rebmann LLP
Pittsburgh, PA
 
"Excellent on Attorney Fee Issues in Florida"
Debra L. Feit
Stratford Law Group LLC
Fort Lauderdale, FL
 
"Nation's Top Scholar on Attorney Fees in Class Actions"
Brian T. Fitzpatrick
Vanderbilt Law School
Nashville, TN
 
"Great Leader in Analyzing Legal Bills for Insurers"
Richard Zujac
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Philadelphia, PA